16

I've heard that Arthur Conan Doyle's depiction of Professor Moriarty was inspired by several real-life figures, including Adam Worth. Given Doyle's wide-ranging set of villains and antagonists in the Sherlock Holmes canon, I'd assume that this is not the only case.

Did Doyle base any other antagonists on real-life criminals or figures, and is there evidence to support this?

15

1. Professor Moriarty

I'd like to go into Moriarty in more detail, because Worth was not the only inspiration for Moriarty.

Doyle did not simply draw on Worth for inspiration. Masters of Crime states that Doyle himself only acknowledged being inspired by one criminal: Jonathan Wild, a 17th and 18th century master of the criminal underworld. In The Valley of Fear, he is even referenced by Holmes:

Everything comes in circles—even Professor Moriarty. Jonathan Wild was the hidden force of the London criminals, to whom he sold his brains and his organization on a fifteen per cent commission.

The evidence pointing to Worth as another inspiration is largely circumstantial but quite apparent. He was once referred to as "the Napoleon of crime" by a Scotland yard detective (see Masters of Crime), a phrase Doyle my have appropriated for Moriarty. Like Moriarty - and like Wild - he was famous for creating a large criminal network in London to which he could seldom be traced.

2. Irene Adler

Adler, who appears in A Scandal in Bohemia may have been inspired by several real-life singers and courtesans. The New Annotated Sherlock Holmes lists quite a few, including Lola Montez (mistress of Ludwig I of Bavaria, which hearkens to the story), Lillie Langtry (whose career is similar to Adler's), Pauline Lucca, Laura Bell, and others. The Doctor and the Detective also mentions one Ludmilla Hubel, whose love affair with Archduke Johann Salvator parallels Adler's relationship with the King of Bohemia. Viktor Adler, an Austrian politician, may be the source of the name "Adler".

3. Charles Augustus Milverton

Doyle's famous blackmailer, who appeared in The Adventure of Charles Augustus Milverton, bears a striking similarity to the 19th century Charles Augustus Howell in both name and occupation (blackmailer and art dealer). London After Midnight states the Doyle himself admitted as such, although I'm still trying to confirm this.

4. John Clay

It's also worth noting that Masters of Crime, which drew parallels between Moriarty and Wild and Worth, same book states that John Clay, the hidden antagonist of The Red-Headed League, can be similarly traced. He shares characteristics of Worth and a criminal rival of Worth's named Max Shinburn - even though Doyle did not, at the time of the story's publication, know about either of the two. The author describes Clay as a "dummy run" for Moriarty, although Doyle could not have had Worth in mind at the time.

It seems possible that Doyle based Clay on Wild, though. The obvious similarity is the ability to hide behind accomplices, distance oneself from the crime, and avoid capture, which Clay has, according to Holmes, used quite often in the past. Both, too, seem to have spun vast webs - perhaps not quite at the level of Moriarty - covering a wide range of illegal activities, from petty theft to murder.

  • 1
    As a bonus, try analysing what Moffat and Gatiss based their antagonists on! – Gallifreyan Jan 27 '17 at 15:34
  • @Gallifreyan No, please don't. Or at least take that stuff to Movies & TV SE instead. Let's not soil a perfectly good literary question about Doyle's Sherlock Holmes by bringing that shallow and cheap-quip-packed TV series into it. – Rand al'Thor Jan 27 '17 at 22:56
  • 1
    @Randal'Thor it was <sarcasm>. Besides, that series is not at all bad! – Gallifreyan Jan 28 '17 at 8:21
  • 2
    @Randal'Thor I would accept that critique for the fourth season, but the first three are brilliant. Conversely, the fourth season actually has antagonists which might be traced back to real people, but the first three don't. – Lauren Ipsum Jan 28 '17 at 11:44

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.