7

Because of Catch 22's twisted timeline, while reading it, several times I had the distinct impression that what seemed to have happened so far in the past was different from what apparently happened in the past of the current point:

(apparent past)
-------------------+-- (present)
-------------------/
(story of the past)

I could never quite put my finger on a specific problem. Are there any internal inconsistencies in Catch 22, or was I just confused by Heller?

  • Could you give some examples of times when you were confused by the book (with page numbers)? – user111 Jan 21 '17 at 19:18
  • @Hamlet as I said, I couldn't pin down a specific problem – muru Jan 21 '17 at 19:20
9

Yes there are, but they are minor.

This is exactly the feeling Joseph Heller wanted to provoke. He both intentionally and by 'planned accident' planted anachronisms in the story, and there are some real mistakes as well. The last category is small though, as you noted.

The story takes place during WW2. But it was never intended as 'a realistic novel about WW2'. It was more intended to depict general truths about the madness of bureaucracy. Joseph Heller admits to having little actual war experience, having been overseas for less than a year. Catch-22 was started eight years after the war and written over a period of eight years. Post-war anachronisms in the text abound and were deliberate. Still, the convoluted storyline was carefully designed using note cards and is consistent but for smaller details. It was a first novel, and truly complicated as well.

One inconsistency is about the number of missions over time. Between September 1943 and May 1944 the required number of missions is raised by 10 and Yossarian flies 9. But there is also mention of a number of 6 missions in 6 days in September. Implausible at best.

A comprehensive list together with a chronology:

Spindrift and the Sea: Structural Patterns and Unifying Elements in Catch 22 Clinton S. Burhans, Jr.
Twentieth Century Literature
Vol. 19, No. 4 (Oct., 1973), pp. 239-250

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.