3

I came upon this on p. 167 of National Geographic Stunning Photographs.

I quote Mystery Scene, because G.M. Malliet has a B.A. in journalism and an M.A. in psychology; she also received an M.Phil. degree from the University of Cambridge (psychology of education) and did graduate study in sociology at Oxford University.

Thurber’s is a subversive style of writing I associate with the British, so gifted at making us laugh by taking an ordinary scene and piling occurrence upon happenstance, leading us toward a somehow inevitable and happy, if goofy, outcome. As Thurber said, “Humor is emotional chaos remembered in tranquility.” First posit a ridiculous, Python-esque setup, then coax the reader until he accepts the implausible as real. Add fantastic, startling touches, until your Walter Mitty is thoroughly entrenched in a mad world spinning out of his control.

What does James Thurber mean by "Humor is emotional chaos remembered in tranquility"?

4

TL;DR: This quotation is the result of a kind of collaboration between William Wordsworth, James Thurber, and Leonard Bacon.

Here’s Thurber’s original version, or at least the version as quoted by Max Eastman—I have not been able to find the original, but presumably it was one of Thurber’s columns in the New Yorker:

I think humor is the best that lies closest to the familiar, to that part of the familiar which is humiliating, distressing, even tragic. Humor is a kind of emotional chaos told about calmly and quietly in retrospect. There is always a laugh in the utterly familiar. If a play is going on on the stage, a love scene, say, and from the wings a Scotty should wander on, with muddy paws, having got away from its owner’s dressing room, and if the Scotty should jump up on the best sofa and lie down, it would be funnier than if a kangaroo popped in.

James Thurber, quoted in Max Eastman (1936). Enjoyment of Laughter, p. 342. New York: Simon and Schuster.

Thurber clearly meant to allude to Wordsworth’s famous description of poetry:

I have said that poetry is the spontaneous overflow of powerful feelings: it takes its origin from emotion recollected in tranquillity: the emotion is contemplated till by a species of reaction the tranquillity gradually disappears, and an emotion, similar to that which was before the subject of contemplation, is gradually produced, and does itself actually exist in the mind.

William Wordsworth (1800). Lyrical Ballads, second edition, volume I, p. xxxiii. London: Longman.

But the allusion is rather clumsy: perhaps Thurber was relying on his memory of Wordsworth. The critic Leonard Bacon, in a 1936 review of Enjoyment of Laughter, spotted the allusion, and proposed an improvement:

This is what he [Thurber] says: “Humor is a kind of emotional chaos told about calmly and quietly in retrospect.” The phrasing is careless, but “emotion recollected in tranquillity” meant poetry to Wordsworth. Would “emotional chaos recollected in tranquillity”—or anything else have meant humor to him?

Leonard Bacon (1936). Review of The Enjoyment of Laughter by Max Eastman. In Saturday Review of Literature, volume 15, p. 10.

The substitution of “remembered” for “recollected” must have taken place some time between 1936 and 1956, for the quotation appears in this form (attributed, wrongly, to Thurber) in a review in The Publishers Weekly, volume 190, p. 63.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy