4

Philip Larkin's poem "Days" contains the following lines:

Where can we live but days?

Ah, solving that question
Brings the priest and the doctor

What does "solving" mean here? I assume it could mean the following:

  1. looking for the answer (the continuous and unfinished process of trying to find the answer)
  2. the solution itself (the fact of having the question solved)
  3. both

Which of these is the most obvious/natural use of this word, licencia poetica aside?

3

The answer to “where can we live but days?” is “nowhere”, and so “solving that question” is a metaphor for dying, which “brings the priest and the doctor” to administer the last rites and sign the death certificate. The verb “solve” has a couple of meanings that are appropriate in this context:

solve, v. 3.a. To explain, clear up, resolve, answer.

5. To dissolve, put an end to, settle.

Oxford English Dictionary

1

I think "solving that question" means successfully finding somewhere to live besides days. So "solving" just means finding the answer or answers to. In math, solving x squared equals nine means figuring out that x equals three or minus three.

What might the answers be? Maybe living at night, or at random times, perhaps ignoring time completely, coming late or early for doctor's appointments, going to church at night, and/or going generally mad?

Though it could mean death, as pointed out in at least one prior answer, I think it could also mean (or allude to) some sort of insanity or evil or nonconformism so extreme that one is thought to be in need of help and/or management.

The phrase "in their long coats", suggests to me "men in white coats", and the idea that the doctor in his white coat and the priest in his black coat are coming to apply pressure to the person to live a more typical life.

The priest and the doctor are running over the fields. It suggests some kind of emergency that they are running, which could be that someone is dying, but also that someone is getting out of hand, though not so much that the police or army is needed. But I do wonder why "over the fields". A doctor or priest would normally come by road, surely? What could this be alluding to? Maybe doctor and priest means doctor, priest, policeman, soldier, and every other representative of society that can be called upon to get a person to act more normal.

New contributor
Matthew Christopher Bartsh is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering. Check out our Code of Conduct.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.