3

I'm more interested in literature than law here. I think this means the same thing as "your rights end where mine begin"? Scalia iss alluding to Henry David Thoreau, but my English is too unproficient to read Thoreau. Why does Scalia allude to Thoreau? What's "beau ideal"?

   An example of an opinion rejecting the evaluative portion of a policy argument is Justice Scalia's separate concurring opinion the "nude dancing" case Barnes v. Glen Theatre.323 In finding that there was no First Amendment right to perform or view nude dancing, Scalia wrote, "There is no basis for thinking that our society ever shared the Thoreauvian 'you-may-do-what-you-like-so-long- as-it-does-not-injure-someone-else' beau ideal—much less for thinking that it was written into the Constitution."324

Wilson Huhn. The Five Types of Legal Argument (2 ed, 2014). Pg 140.

scanned pages from Wilson Huhn's book The Five Types of Legal Argument, an excerpt of which is quoted above

3
  • 1
    Hi and welcome to Literature Stack Exchange. I don't think we need the scanned image; the quote itself is sufficient. Or do you have a specific reason for including the scanned pages? – Tsundoku Nov 10 '20 at 10:55
  • 'beau ideal' is French for 'beautiful ideal'. So it means "There is no basis for thinking that our society ever shared the beautiful ideal that you may do what you like, so long as it doesn't injure someone else' presented by Thoreau – Ángel Nov 10 '20 at 23:40
  • @Tsundoku I included the scanned pages just for completeness and context. I didn't know if one para. was enough. – user11334 Nov 12 '20 at 4:36
2

Thoreau was a proponent of limited government. His famous essay Civil Disobedience begins:

I heartily accept the motto, "That government is best which governs least"; and I should like to see it acted up to more rapidly and systematically. Carried out, it finally amounts to this, which also I believe- "That government is best which governs not at all"; and when men are prepared for it, that will be the kind of government which they will have.

Thoreau took the motto "That government is best which governs least" from an unsigned editorial in the first issue of The United States Magazine and Democratic Review (1837). This quote from the editorial explains Scalia's characterization of Thoreau's political philosophy:

The best government is that which governs least.... Government should have as little as possible to do with the general business and interests of the people. If it once undertake these functions as its rightful province of action, it is impossible to say to it, "thus far shalt thou go, and no farther." (p. 6–7)

In other words, government should not regulate anything that it does not absolutely have to:

Its domestic action should be confined to the administration of justice, for the protection of the natural equal rights of the citizen, and the preservation of social order. (p. 7)

This is a libertarian, laissez-faire ideology. Under such an ideology, viewing nude dancing would not be banned. If someone is willing to dance nude, and someone else willing to watch, it's not the government's business to step in and outlaw that.

Scalia argues that beautiful as this philosophy might be, it is not widely shared in American society. He also says it cannot be found in the Constitution and so is not fundamental to American government. He therefore says that regulating nude dancing is something that would fall under the government's remit.

Personally, of course, I find neither this alleged beau ideal nor Antonin Scalia's jurisprudence the slightest bit attractive, nor even intellectually honest, but that's neither here nor there.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy