Please don't look at this post if you haven't read Agatha Christie's The Hollow, in case of spoilers!!!

After reading The Hollow, there are still a few points I do not quite understand. I would feel very grateful if anyone can help me answer the following questions:

  1. Did Agatha write any hint at the early stage of this book that foreshadows that John wanted Henrietta to protect Gerda? Or Henrietta literally immediately understood that John wanted her to protect Gerda from the police by saying Henrietta's name at the moment of his death? This latter explanation sounds unbelievable to me!
  2. How was Poirot able to find the revolver? Henrietta said that she hid the revolver inside the clay model, which in general police won't destroy an artist's masterpiece. This makes sense to me. But Poirot said, "The fact that you chose to model a horse. The horse of Troy was the unconscious association in your mind." Did Poirot went to Henrietta's studio and immediately realized that the revolver should be inside the horse model once he saw the model? How was Poirot able to recognize that immediately?
  3. I still don't understand why near the end of the book, Gerda must (at least tried to) murder Henrietta?
  • 2
    You have some interesting questions here, but can you please post each of them as a separate question? You can copy the introduction and combine it with the second question to create a new post, and do the same with the third question. That way, each answer can focus on one specific issue, and each response can be compared and voted on for quality. I know this may be a bit inconvenient, but that is just how this site works. Have fun and don't worry too much about the spoilers ;-)
    – Tsundoku
    Commented May 11, 2020 at 11:44

1 Answer 1

  1. The explanation seems extraordinary, but that’s what Henrietta says, and if she’s lying then we have nothing better.

    “Because John asked me to! That’s what he meant when he said ‘Henrietta.’ It was all there in that one word. He was asking me to protect Gerda. You see, he loved Gerda… I think he loved Gerda much better than he ever knew he did. Better than Veronica Cray—better than me. Gerda belonged to him, and John liked things that belonged to him… He knew that if anyone could protect Gerda from the consequences of what she’d done, I could—And he knew that I would do anything he wanted, because I loved him."

    Agatha Christie (1946). The Hollow, chapter 29. New York: Dodd, Mead and Company.

    There are three clues to this explanation, though you would have to be very astute to put them together. First, there is a clue that the manner of John’s dying message is important:

    (“Henrietta!” the dying man had said. He had said it in a very curious way. A way that reminded Poirot of something—of some incident… now, what was it? No matter, it would come to him.)

    Chapter 11.

    Second, we learn what kind of ‘incident’ Poirot was reminded of, and the dying man’s manner of speaking:

    “Dr. Christow knew perfectly what he was saying. His voice was as alive and conscious as that of a doctor doing a vital operation who says sharply and urgently, ‘Nurse, the forceps, please.’”

    Chapter 18.

    Third, we are told how Poirot interprets the man’s state of mind:

    “His voice was urgent—that is all I can say—urgent. It seemed to me neither accusing nor emotional—but urgent, yes! And of one thing I am sure. He was in full possession of his faculties. He spoke—yes, he spoke like a doctor—a doctor who has, say, a sudden surgical emergency on his hands—a patient who is bleeding to death, perhaps…”

    Chapter 19.

    The obvious way to interpret this analogy is that John himself was the patient, since he was literally bleeding to death as he spoke. But that can’t be right, since a doctor can’t be his own patient. It must be the case that someone else was the patient. Looked at this way round, the patient corresponds to Gerda, who is metaphorically ‘bleeding to death’: that is, facing conviction and death by hanging.

  2. Poirot did not find the revolver by deducing that it was in the sculpture of the horse, it was the other way round: he deduced that it must have been hidden in the horse because he found the revolver in his own hedge:

    Hercule Poirot had been staring out of the window for some moment… His eye had been attracted by an irregularity in the symmetry of his domain.

    He said now:

    “You want a solid fact! Eh bien, unless I am much mistaken there is a solid fact in the hedge by my gate.”

    Chapter 26.

    Shortly before this discovery Poirot had met Henrietta in the woods coming from the direction of his house, and she had said, “I have just been to call upon you. But you were out.” That gave Henrietta the opportunity to plant the revolver in his hedge. She had just come from her studio in London, so she must have brought it with her, and since the police had searched her studio, it must have been well hidden.

    We are given a clue to the hiding place, though again you would have to be very astute to follow Poirot’s line of thought.

    “Nothing there either. She went straight back to Chelsea and we’ve kept an eye on her ever since.† The revolver isn’t in her studio or in her possession. She was quite pleasant about the search—seemed amused. Some of her fancy stuff gave our man quite a turn. He said it beat him why people wanted to do that kind of thing—statues all lumps and swellings, bits of brass and aluminum twisted into fancy shapes, horses that you wouldn’t know were horses—”

    Poirot stirred a little.

    “Horses, you say?”

    “Well a horse. If you’d call it a horse! If people want to model a horse why don’t they go and look at a horse!”

    “A horse,” repeated Poirot.

    Grange turned his head.

    “What is there about that that interests you so, M. Poirot? I don’t get it.”

    Association—a point of the psychology.”

    Chapter 26.

    † This must be a mistake, as if it were true then they would have seen her put the revolver in Poirot’s hedge.

  3. The only explanation we get is that once Gerda realized that Henrietta knew she was the murderer, she was afraid that Henrietta would betray her:

    “Oh, no, it was meant for you. It was in your teacup.”

    “For me?” Henrietta’s voice was incredulous. “But I was trying to help her.”

    “That did not matter. Have you not seen a dog caught in a trap—it sets its teeth into anyone who touches it. She saw only that you knew her secret and so you too must die.”

    Chapter 29.

  • 1
    Your answers are fantastic!!! It is so amazing that you recognize so many details for the first two questions! Commented May 10, 2020 at 22:49

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.